Ronja R.
Absolutely amazing, loved all the flavours! Especially the Black Forest one, the cherry in the dark AND vegan chocolate? Amazing. Would love to be able to order more of that flavour.
E R.
I love this chocolate.
The flavours are like nothing you'll find in the shops.
I've given a rating of 4 only because I love dark chocolate and I'd love the option of choosing more dark chocolate. But totally understand it's a mystery box.
Annie M.
Sooo good! Followed chocolate smiths on instagram for a while and so glad I decided to purchase! Will definitely be buying again! A subscription might definitely have to happen
Laura H.
This is my second mystery box, the January 2024 mystery box was so much better with more variety. I suppose it is down to personal preference, I love most of your chocolate but I have to say the Peaches and Cream bar was very dissapointing. I was expecting more of a fruity taste but got an overload of sickly sugary buttercream on top of white chocolate. I feel the bar had much more potential than it turned out. The Cranachan bar from the first mystery box I have to say is probably your best bar ever made!!
Jennifer K.
Three full sized and a mini, all flavours we’ve not tried before and all different from each other. Absolutely loved it, hubby was just as excited especially seeing sticky toffee pudding and cinder toffee.
BRETT M.
I shared some with my family just because there are bars in there that I don’t really like tbh but that’s ok!!
Denise J.
I ordered a mystery pack for the first time. I was not disappointed plenty of variety included. 4 large bars and a mini bar
Kirsty M.
Was looking forward to this mystery pack but was unfortunately abit disappointed in the selection. Three of the four were white chocolate, the bubblegum one was more minty than bubblegum and the peaches & cream was abit bland and didn’t taste of anything however it won’t stop me from purchasing other items
Joanna T.
It was great having the surprise and was good value.
Gemma Q.
We loved our chocolate and I’ve told my friends, happy customer- our favourite is the sticky toffee bar
Chloe C.
Brilliant selection that I received!
Samantha M.
Always delicious and new flavors I normally wouldn’t pick
Kirsty M.
I always love a delivery, but I was abit disappointed in this selection. 3 are white chocolate. The bubblegum one tasted more minty than bubblegum and the peaches and cream didn’t really taste of anything, was abit bland. It won’t stop me from ordering again, I’ve ordered 2 different selections this week
Emily F.
The mystery packs always are so so good! I love the surprise of what bars you’re going to get and they’re all of course delicious
Kirsty M.
I was abit disappointed, was expecting the flavours what was uploaded on insta, I know you can receive some but not all 4 flavours. However 3 were white chocolate. The bubblegum was more minty than bubblegum & the peaches and cream tastes of nothing, rather bland
Jake A.
Overpriced I may as well picked my own chocolate which I would have got more for the money
Kirsty M.
Abit disappointed, 3 out of 4 are white chocolate. Also the mystery packs were advertised on insta with 4 full bars and only received 2 of the flavours. The bubblegum one tastes rather strange, more minty than bubblegum and the peaches & cream one doesn’t really taste of anything. I will continue ordering single bars but probably not they mystery pack again
Lisa C.
This was delicious as I love Lemon meringue and chocolate so together was a dream come true. All my family also enjoyed this but however I personally would have preferred more lemon in the egg but that's personal choice not a reflection on the chocolate bar at all
Stephen M.
The quality of the chocolate is not in question but only getting 3 regular sized bars feels like poor value when you are not explicitly choosing. I have saw that others get more which would be better if you are not able to choose.
Darrin
Having placed numerous orders we had built up over 900 reward points with the Chocolate Smiths so we decided to redeem these and purchase a £40 mystery box subscription. First of all their system would only let us redeem 700 points maximum so a discount of £7 not the £9 we had earned by being a loyal frequent customer. Then we were informed that reward point discounts could not be used toward payment of a subscription leaving us to purchase the more expensive single purchase option (funny how that reduced our reward further in their favour). Then came the usual long wait to receive the items from them…. Once our order finally arrived, weeks later, we then discovered just how little value for money our £40 mystery box contained. The box is marketed as “at least £40 worth of chocolate plus a freebie” we received the following - 5 x 100g bars, going by an average full bar price of £6.50 our £40 mystery box order contained just £32.50 worth of chocolate and certainly no freebie! (see photo if reading this review on the Chocolate Smiths website, assuming they haven’t curated out the bad reviews again) Needless to say we definitely won’t be subscribing any longer and we caution anyone thinking of purchasing a mystery box not to do so…..
Holly C.
Got a great mix of treats- great value for money!
Faye w.
Weve had a few mystery boxes and my kids and us adults absolutly love them!!
Alison R.
I got 3 full size bars and one small bar, all amazing!
Ladien C.
Have wanted to try the chocolate smiths for soo long. I order a mystery bundle but it was a bad choice. Opened the box excited to try the bars with my family and no one liked any of the chocolate. Really bizarre flavours. I had to him it all. I would advise buying the bars you want rather than a mystery box. It’s a lot of money for chocolate and I will have to do another order now to order particular ones to try.
Martha .
Absolutely Love how it was packaged! Am yet to try the bars but flavours sounds really nice. Only thing is I’m a bit disappointed to receive a smaller bar as looking at other orders majority have received 4 full sized bars
Samantha M.
2nd time I’ve ordered a mystery pack and I am seriously blown away. I love getting these because honestly I’m not that adventurous or decisive on what I want. Every bar was so wonderful and it’s so fun getting to open your package when it arrives!
Tane B.
We love the box, it was for a birthday present for my daughter. Unfortunately there were chocolates sent which were suitable for adults. My fault I didn't mention this when I ordered. But she loved to to she could eat. Thank you.
Emily B.
Incredible chocolate! So creative and delicious flavours, I want to try all of it!! The raspberry Caramel bar was probably my favourite and my husband loved the maple pancake. Would 100% order again !
penelope m.
Not impressed with the bars that are in this pack I don’t like alcohol favours in chocolate and I don’t like coffee in chocolate.
the bubblegum flavour was too sweet so this pack was not to my liking.
Jacqueline T.
This chocolate was so SO good! I saw a video on TikTok and thought I'd just give it a go - I'm terribly pleased I did! The international shipping was quick (I'm in Canada) and it was well packaged. I definitely will be purchasing again as I shared it with my family and they loved it too!
Abbs
The mystery pack is just a way to get rid of the flavours no one wants to eat…
Flavours included
Banana and rum- have given away so cannot judge
Bubble gum- absolutely the worst chocolate bar I’ve ever had in my
Life
Carrot cake - which tasted like straight cloves and raw spices both me and my partner spat it out
Coffee and honeycomb- this was the only edible bar but still tasted like licking the bottom of a coffee can
I paid £20 and waited nearly 2 weeks for this absolute disappointment. This is a tiktok business just make the cool bars to break open for views and then sell absolutely dross to paying customers
Sophie L.
The chocolate is nice but in my bundle three of the four bars were white chocolate and two of those had sprinkles, so there wasn’t a massive range. Would recommend for white chocolate lovers! The birthday cake bar also had a best before date that expired the week before it was even delivered which isn’t ideal. I have ordered separate chocolate bars before which have been great, so will stick to that next time.
Georgina M.
It was pretty good variety! Not all the flavours are for me but still good!
Rosann H.
2nd £40 Mystery pack I've brought and very happy with it especially since I got it in the sale as well. I've always got a varied flavour selection, defo worth getting if your not sure what to try first.
Nicola S.
Great selection of chocolate bars as always and thanks for a bar of the Scottish Crannock: I love this one!!!
Scout P.
This mystery pack is truly such a great deal, you get to try new unique flavours and it’s always a surprises which makes it even more exciting. My family and I ordered the mystery pack together with other bars and we really appreciated that they took the time to give us chocolate bars that we hadn’t ordered so that we didn’t have any doubles, it really shows how lovely and caring this team is ❤️
Megan P.
I don’t have any pictures but an excellent selection of chocolate, all delicious and not necessarily flavours I would have picked. Really pleased with these
Alison H.
Prompt and efficient service
michelle m.
Mystery pack order. 3 yummy bars- carrot cake, birthday cake and a ??? Latte bar (can't remember the name- it went first! Lol!) Also got a bubblegum bar, which I had last time I ordered mystery pack too, and this was the one disappointment. Find the flavour really strong and unpleasant. Its such a "marmite" flavour I think , so ended up giving it away again. Just a personal taste thing - I don't like bubblegum either- but probably would put me off buying the mystery pack in future as with my luck i d end up with it again!
Uroosa A.
Unfortunately asked to not receive a specific chocolate and it was sent in the box.
Madihah M.
Always a great mix of chocolate! Got three big bars and one little one and they are a fantastic selection!
Love a mystery pack as you don’t know what you’re getting and so may get something you wouldn’t normally try and it’s also a great starting point for newbies to the chocolate smiths! (And for when your spoilt for choice and can’t choose!)
Samantha M.
This was the best chocolate I have ever had. The flavors were so interesting and delightful! I’m normally not a big white chocolate fan but I loved the snowball chocolate bar. Not to mention my order arrived very promptly and adorably packaged. I will definitely be ordering again!
Charlotte T.
I was disappointed in this month's selection, I felt like it was left over stock from December and I only like 1 bar out of the 3 large and 1 small I got. First one I have been disappointed with may I add, maybe made worse when seeing the Instagram reel of what would be in this months and I didn't get any of those delicious looking bars. Hoping next one is back to its usual delights
patricia m.
Always a great treat opening these boxes . The issue is which bar to attack first lol
Emma G.
Ordered this for a family member for Xmas! They loved it! Great variety of chocolate for them to try for the first time!
Rosann H.
I purchased the smaller surprise pack a few months ago and loved it so thought I'd give the bigger version a go, I got 7 full sized bars which for that price is amazing especially for handmade chocolate. They were a mix of normal and seasonal Christmas flavours, some I wouldn't have picked myself but when I actually tried them I found I really liked the flavours, bonus was I got a coconut flavour which I love and a few diff salted caramel flavours each one just hits differently. Will defo be buying again and will recommend to others.
Fiona K.
Brought the £20 mystery box. Absolutely worth it chocolate was so tasty
Charlotte H.
The chocolate was delicious! The packaging was so fun and creative and it feels good to support a small business.
Will definitely order again!
Victoria A.
Great selection. All beautifully packaged and the ones already open are delicious!
Desiree M.
Always love receiving the mystery packs They are always good value for money. You get way more chocolate than you pay for. All very delicious
Callum P.
Really nice chocolate, my partner loved it! Bought as a Xmas present, the chocolate was in great condition and was not in anyway effected during transit.
Will be ordering again !
Jessica G.
I absolutely love your chocolate but every time I do a mystery pack I get 4 chocolate bars, this time at Christmas getting 3 paying £23 I was very disappointed and didn’t actually like the flavour this time, I was hoping for Christmas flavour being December x
Sarah F.
Just wow!!!
Every bar is amazing, you selected flavours I’d have never chosen for myself but they were all delicious! Now all other chocolate tastes inferior!
Peter S.
My wife loves them the flavours are the best great tastes
Lily S.
The banoffee one is legitimately overpowered, please nerf
Eilidh M.
Just the best chocolate - the caramel bar has changed my life.
Sophie K.
I love a surprise so this was the perfect choice for me. Eating ana’s biscuit tin at the moment. OMG beautiful caramel chocolate. Can’t wait to try the others.
Jacqueline T.
Great selection of chocolate flavours. It’s a gift for my hubby so can’t comment on taste but they look fab
Lorraine J.
Hello,
I am sorry to say it never arrived.
Regards
Lorraine x
Merry Christmas
Jennifer K.
Great value and extra exciting in that it's a surprise! Let's face it, there wasn't going to be anything in there that I wasn't going to enjoy . Got to sample the All Things Nice bar which is amazing!
BRETT M.
They all taste so good I’m so happy with them!!
Emma L.
I was very surprised to see that the 20 pounds mystery box included 4 chocolate bars - and each one sounds amazing! Such a fun way to try exciting and different chocolate bars :)
Sarah D.
Loved all the chocolate it was amazing
Vincent C.
Great chocolate.
Loved it. Ordered a mystery box which was 4 full bars of fantastic chocolate
Kelly D.
Nice bit of variety and included flavours I hadn't even thought of. Four bars and cute packaging.
Emma L.
Pretty disappoint to have got 2 of the same flavour despite the listing saying they guarantee wouldn’t get 2 of the same.
Otherwise, it’s good chocolate and I imagine would be fun to get a mix of options.
Tammy H.
These were great! I got 2 full sized bars of the fruity Halloween flavors (orange and lime), and full sized "secret" bar (Maple pancake), and a mini bubblegum sundea. The maple one was some of the best chocolate I've had in my life! Seriously cannot overstate how delicious it was. The fruity ones were great too, although the orange was very subtle, they both had a good balance of flavors. Wasn't a huge fun of the bubblegum one, but it certainly was bizarre! Overall the mystery box was a great experience. Would recommend if you're looking to try the Chocolate Smiths out and want a good variety.
Craig P.
Great selection and the chocolate is so creative. Had the Halloween bars and a the banoffee and brownie.
Jessica G.
Buying a mystery pack allowed me to try some flavours I maybe normally wouldn't have tried and I'm so thankful I did. All my bars were amazing but my particular favourite was the Quay bar, when you got a piece that had all 3 components it really was an experience!
Helen T.
So excited by my mystery box. The bizzare spooky orang was lovely, as was the salted caramel. Xx
Rosann H.
I ordered my first £20 mystery box to see what kind of selection I'd receive, I ended up getting 4 full size bars 2 of them where halloween special bars which was a nice surprise. All 4 tasted really good and as I recieved ones that had fluffy fillings I followed instructions to keep them in the fridge to keep them fresh and to take out for room temp to eat and they still tasted just as good a week later after being opened. Does take a couple of weeks from being ordered to be delivered but they are worth the wait for the work put into the chocolates being made.
Phoua Y.
I was so excited to receive my mystery box. It is literally the one thing I look forward to every month. My husband and I really enjoyed the Halloween selection this time around. But by far our favorite bar was the limited edition golden milk chocolate maple pancake bizarre bar.
Sandra J.
I had to email to ask for my box to be postponed as we were going on holiday, the customer service was amazing and they waiting until we got home to post it and we received it 2 days later. This was a belated birthday present for my son and he loved it all the bars were Halloween themed and well worth the money.
Sam C.
A fantastic mystery box, the I’scream bar in particular was amazing! Also the customer service from the chocolate smiths is exceptional, my mum ordered and asked if it could possibly be sent earlier as it was for a religious holiday and the chocolate smiths got it sent early without question, thank you so much!
MISS S.
First time ordering with this fantastic company and am very impressed and amazing tastes. I seen one of your Tik Tok videos and after that I was obsessed! Me and my niece love them are favourites ones where S’lime and the peanut clutter. Unexpected but delicious looking forward to my next order I love strawberries chocolate as well.
christine f.
The chocolate is good, I love the fact you are supporting a smaller business. The only two set backs were the package took a long time to come and when it did the chocolate was for Halloween, shame I got it on 2 nd November.
Camelia Z.
I don't have pictures to share. In fact this is the downside of these chocolates. They have this tendancy of finishing off and then you feel sad and have to order more. Because they are absolutely delicious. The long delivery time...worth the wait. Keep doing what you are doing as chocolatiers!
Chloe C.
I received a great selection of chocolate bars and all tasted delicious and looked like little pieces of artwork! Would definitely recommend.
Zoe D.
Such fantastic customer service from these talented confectioners! We emailed about getting this pack for a buddy and they not only sorted us an order quicker than we'd hoped, but stuffed it with autumnal spooky flavours to die for! We naughtily kept the lime fluff for ourselves . Thank you for such a great experience. We'll be back!
Charlotte R.
So this is my second Mystery Box and it was absolutely fantastic, I love trying all the different flavours. My little payday treat! Thank you for for creating such delicious chocolate. I look forward to many more orders.
Kelly D.
After waiting at the window for two and a half weeks it came and it was so pretty to unbox. The three big bars were seasonal, which I hoped for and there was a little 40g bar. Super nice to look at the packaging and think about how much efforts gone in to making the chocolate. Haven't tried them yet cause I promised to share but can't wait.
SARAH S.
I love getting a mystery pack, but I’d love to have more variety. All of my bars were white chocolate based and I’m a big fan of milk and dark chocolate, so felt a little bit disappointed to not get any this time.
Kayleigh H.
Great tasting chocolate, I loved my mystery box.. thank you
Helen P.
Lovely chocolate, really enjoyed the orange one. Love all the packaging designs.
Emily K.
I loved the chocolate and lime bar , it was amazing, and I enjoyed the orange cream one too.
I wasn’t sure on the sour apple, the flavours were exactly as described, just not the bar for me.
And the bubble gum one, wow the flavour was undoubtedly bubble gum which was awesome, however I don’t like bubble gum , great Halloween box and loved the graphics
Nikki D.
We are early into our subscription but already loving the amount of bars and the different flavours
Holly B.
Got some amazing classics and some exclusives that were amazing! I always request something within the mystery pack and is always adhered to!
Adam T.
Its amazing choices
Jagoda Z.
That was my first mystery box and I’m not disappointed:) Very good chocolate and rich selection of flavours
Rebecca F.
Literally a child in a candy/sweets shop upon arrival of this box. This is my second subscription box and it was everything + I imagined. So thrilled to receive Halloween treats, which are so beautifully demonstrated on TikTok. Can't wait to -not ration these bars- this festive weekend.
Victoria B.
Didn’t live this mystery box
Steve M.
Great product, well packaged & delivered exactly when expected.
Kolsuma B.
Worth every penny.
Zoe M.
Was very happy with the selection of chocolate in my mystery pack .
First there was the ritz one which I think has to be my fav bar I’ve tried (and I’ve tried a lot )
also had the birthday cake it was lovely and creamy with a zing of jam .
had the biscuit choc first time trying and it was lovely with a contrast of milk and dark choc with lovely biscuits inside ,
xtra bar was the banana bread choc that was so lovely I just can’t fault the taste and quality of the chocolate bars that’s what I keep ordering .
Manon W.
I loved every bite of this month chocolate. The Gold Chocolate Maple Pancake one was the best.
Alice L.
Brilliant value mystery pack! Was awesome trying so many different delicious bars
Jacqueline V.
Absolutely loved them! I found them on TikTok on my fyp and kept craving them till I finally caved and ordered. The packaging of the chocolate bars was so cute! I also loved how they included an ice pack to keep them cold while they came all the way to the states where it was 95 degrees (35 degrees Celsius) when they were delivered! Absolutely will order again!
Gillian M.
We enjoyed trying the mystery pack as usual nobody owned up to finishing all chocolate bars really love buying the chocolate smiths chocolate …⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️