Couldn't load pickup availability
Overall rating: 4.3 / 5 from 47 reviews.
This was a shared experience between the two of us, omg, the taste combination in both halves was amazing, the chocolate was so thick and the filling so tasty, I really enjoyed the white chocolate with the thick toffee centre, the milk chocolate side was equally tasty, a great combination, im just really glad I was lucky enough to secure an order!
I ate this over a week as alot of chocolate! I prefer the cookies and caramel side with the textures and with darker chocolate is balances the sweetness of the caramel out. The white chocolate side with candy apple caramel was bit too sweet for me as white chocolate is already very sweet and this is very thick chocolate. Love this invitation of Halloween, very clever!
Amazing, really liked the treat side the best , but thought the combo was delicious 😋
Bit impractical to eat/cut into pieces because of how thick each side of the pumpkin was, but SO delicious! The cookies & cream side was pure perfection: the flavours, the mixture of crunch and creaminess, the sweetness and yet also slight saltiness - everything was so balanced and came together so nicely. The white choc side might be a bit too much for some (e.g. my partner), but I was completely sold; the apple caramel filling redefined the meaning of the word "decadent", I was addicted within minutes. 10/10! Didn't have space to upload pics of the packaging but that also deserves a special mention, as it was so gorgeous.
Love the design!! The marshmallow fluff side we LOVED!! But we weren’t keen on the apple caramel at all but that it totally a preference thing, the caramel was lovely and buttery but just didn’t get on with the apple flavour!
Nice and glad I ordered but filling was just ok, maybe a fruity filling or something? It was still nice though and a great design
Fantastic chocolate!
Trick or Treat Chocolate Pumpkin 550g *LIMITED EDITION*
Store owner replied: Thank you so much for your lovely review! We’re absolutely delighted that you enjoyed the chocolate, and your support really means a lot to our small team. Thank you again for taking the time to leave a review.
Really enjoyed this combination! The trick side was my favourite of the two 😋
Great flavour, but have to admit that the chocolate was actually a bit too thick. Almost broke a tooth 🤣 Would love to see it with a golden caramel flavour?
Trick or Treat Chocolate Pumpkin 550g *LIMITED EDITION*
Store owner replied: Thank you for the feedback! 😊 We’re really glad you enjoyed the flavour, and we appreciate the note about the thickness too — and that golden caramel idea sounds delicious! 🍫✨
Bought as a gift and they absolutely loved it!
Everything from Chocolate Smiths is of excellent quality. Pumpkin was heavy and had plenty of filling. My favourite side was the Treat, I found the Trick side interesting but not a flavour Id have again (purely personal preference). The Chocolate is amazing and the filling always tastes and feels like a lot of effort has been put into their creation
Looked incredible, a real spectacle bashing it open with the kids! Tasted sublime xx
Fantastic chocolate. I loved the fact that there were 2 different flavours and the packaging was amazing.
Bloddy love these creations. The pumpkin was my favourite so far. The dark chocolate and Oreo side was outrageously good. I love thick chocolate, and these guys nail that.
Great product, love the 2 different flavours. Only slight criticism is in parts the chocolate is very thick in small parts, making it very tough on the teeth even at room temperature. Would get again though!
Lovely contrast in flavours.
Loved the Apple half but we didn’t like the other half
Loved it, delicious
Tasty but really difficult to get into and to eat! The chocolate was really thick at parts which made it unbreakable and the sealing was so strong I almost broke my table getting into it and had to result in using a very large knife, which was scary!
It looked very beautiful, the milk chocolate part of pumpkin was very tasty, but white chocolate part was a bit disappointing... The layer of chocolate was veeeery thick and hard, the apple caramel filling was good, but something was missing. Too sweet, I would add some crumble or biscuit! Overall, it was a nice experience
Omg I couldn’t stop eating this….so delicious.😍😍😍
Wow, a very weighty pumpkin. Very delicious as always.
As ever, clever, quirky and tasty. Fab. Thanks.
I absolutely love the chocolate smiths, however I was a little disappointed with the trick or treat pumpkin, the shell chocolate was very thick, making it hard to break up. The filling to chocolate ratio wasn’t quite on point, with lessor filling and the sour apple caramel was not to my taste. I do love this concept. But I preferred the mini Halloween bars from last year.
Looked great, tasted delicious, but preferred the treat side to the trick side. Wanted to love both sides equally.
Not much filling in the sour apple side, and what there was has pooled in the middle, so the chocolate was very, very thick and hard to eat. The bit that had filling in was very nice. Wouldn't buy again I'm afraid, sorry.
Trick or Treat Chocolate Pumpkin 550g *LIMITED EDITION*
Store owner replied: Thank you so much for your honest feedback 💛 We’re really sorry to hear the filling wasn’t evenly distributed — that definitely doesn’t sound like the balance we aim for. It should be a punchy, playful mix of chocolate and centre all the way through, so we’ll absolutely pass this on to our kitchen team to review. We really appreciate you giving it a try and hope there’s another bar in the range that hits the mark for you!
Beautifully packaged. It was a gift for my teen daughter who thought it was such delicious chocolate which felt indulgent and different, with all the fillings she loved.
Soooo delicious! As with the Easter egg, I loved that I could have two flavours to try. They both were spot on. The sour apple caramel was exceptional. I love things fluffly so the marshmallow side was gorgeous too!
THE best
I thought it tasted delicious and looked really cool. It was very difficult to eat and one opened it made everything all sticky.
Love it
So very very sickly. Couldn’t manage the white chocolate one and regretted eating the other side (but it was tasty for a few bites!)
Trick or Treat Chocolate Pumpkin 550g *LIMITED EDITION*
Store owner replied: Thank you for your feedback 💛 We’re really sorry this one ended up a bit too sweet for you — some of our bars do lean into full-on indulgence, but we totally understand that can be a bit much depending on your taste. We're glad the first few bites hit the spot at least! 😅 We really appreciate you giving it a try and hope there's another flavour in the range that's just right for you! 🍫✨
The Apple caramel taste weird to me. It feels like it’s supposed to be a candy but instead it’s chocolate? And there’s this sort of dissonance that makes me dislike it The dark part of Oreo and marshmallow fluff is personally too sweet for me
Trick or Treat Chocolate Pumpkin 550g *LIMITED EDITION*
Store owner replied: Thank you so much for your thoughtful feedback 💛 We totally get where you’re coming from — that flavour combo is definitely one of our more playful and unusual pairings, and while some people love the candy-meets-chocolate twist, it’s not for everyone. The sweetness can be a bit full-on too, especially with the marshmallow fluff. We really appreciate you giving it a go, and we hope there’s another bar in our range that’s more your vibe! 🍫🍏
It was a present for my nephew who is autistic & he loved it as it was different
I rated this based on the Oreo side, which I loved - great mix of flavours and textures. While I liked the apple caramel on the other half, and normally enjoy buckloads of filling, I found it too much of one thing, and unfortunately I didn't enjoy the thick white chocolate, which I can understand was made less sweet for balance with the filling (it had a kind of "dry" taste to me). I love the creativity of these products though.
Quite simply the best chocolate in the UK , made lovingly by the amazing team up in Newcastle.
Unfortunately we didn’t enjoy the trick as much as the treat, the apple flavour felt to artificial. Though the treat was amazing, maybe just our taste as everything else you offer is amazing
This was my first order with the Chocolate Smiths, and it was sooo worth the wait! Really lovely quality chocolate and the fillings were ample (nobody likes a lack of filling) and really tasty. The whole family enjoyed the pumpkin, so much so that we've ordered some festive bars!
Our pumpkin was amazing. Packaging was beautiful but the flavor was amazing.
The treat pumpkin was unbelievably decadent and perfect.
